Exploring Reinhold Niebuhr and Quite American

Free essays 0 Comments

4

ExploringReinhold Niebuhr and QuiteAmerican

ByStudent Name’s

ExploringReinhold Niebuhr and QuiteAmerican

InTheIrony of American history,Reinhold Niebuhr states that the forefathers of America had hoped andanticipated America to be an Innocent nation1.They dreamt of a nation where justice, free corruption andresponsible use of power will be upheld. Ironically, the nation hasprospered and become so powerful that attaining the foretoldstandards of innocence has become impossible1.America has turned to taking advantage of its economic and militarypower to oppress and gain from less powerful nations. This is quitedemonstrated in the Quiet American movie where America uses CIA, orthe military power to oppress and gain resources from Vietnam.

Thesame ideologies are expressed in the film QuiteAmerican. Thisexpression of the movie is illustrated by the American character,Pyle, a secret CIA agent2.He is sent to America as a representative of the American advocacy.However, his role is different from the expected. Hewas used as anAmerican government tool sent to manipulate and pave the way for theimplementation of American interests in Vietnam. This is an irony ofresponsible use of power by “an innocent nation”

Americais a non-Communist country and being a powerful country, it shouldapprehend the role of democracy and justice to its citizens as wellas advocate for the apprehension of the same in other states of theworld. America has always been on the front line of fightingcorruption, materialism and oppression of justice in non-Communiststates.3However, despite the efforts, America is involved in the ironymaterialism. Reinhold Niebuhr states that America is rather asuccessful practitioner of materialism. In the movie, it is evidentthat America is materialistic and takes advantage of war torn statesto implement their materialistic agenda in the name of foreignadvocacy. The role of Pyle in Vietnam is to advocate for peace andtolerance.4

However,in the real sense, he is a government project to manipulate and stirwar and misunderstanding in the country and hence enable the UnitedStates to have ample time of carrying out their materialistic agendaand policies. This is done at the expense of the lives of theVietnamese. Additionally, the concept of materialism is shown ininstances where Pyle and Fowler date the same woman, Phuong. Phuongis a Vietnamese who has no other option other than have the two menand besafe and survivethe ongoing war. This can be viewed as image materialism where Pyleand Fowler take advantage of Phuong suffering to political unrest andinsecurity in her country.

BibliographyList

QuietAmerica.Directed by Phillip Noyce. Performed by Michael Caine, Brendan Fraserand Do Thi Hai Yen. 2002.

Niebuhr,Reinhold . TheIrony of American History.University of Chicago Press, 2010.

1 Niebuhr, Reinhold . The Irony of American History. University of Chicago Press, 2010

2 Quiet America. Directed by Phillip Noyce. Performed by Michael Caine, Brendan Fraser and Do Thi Hai Yen. 2002

3 Niebuhr, Reinhold . The Irony of American History. University of Chicago Press, 2010

4 Quiet America. Directed by Phillip Noyce. Performed by Michael Caine, Brendan Fraser and Do Thi Hai Yen. 2002